In the current noise about gender identity there is a missing voice from the “gender community”. Well, not totally missing. Afterall Caitlyn Jenner has publicly voiced her feelings about gender identity being pushed on children under the age of eighteen. But … that’s it. Otherwise, the only voices we’re hearing are those of the extreme right wing of political conservatives.
I suppose it was to be expected that the extremists would be as vocal and visible as they have been. That’s the way it has always worked isn’t it. LGBTQ??? activists throw a temper tantrum over some perceived moral injury and the press rushes to wipe their noses and dry their tears. The usual members of congress race to the nearest microphone to express their outrage and swear to get to the “root cause” and fix it, which they never do because there is nothing to fix except attitudes.
So, what I want to do here is share my thoughts, ideas and feelings on the subject of gender identity and how it affects anyone dealing with it. I also want to address what I see as society’s misunderstanding of the real issue.
I first want to make clear the reality of gender dysphoria. Gender dysphoria in simple terms occurs when the set of emotions a person is born with simply do not match the body they were born with. That being said, anyone suffering from that mismatch of nature is simply fooling themselves if they think hormone treatments and surgery make the reality of the body they were born with, not have any effect on the way others as well as themselves see them. I can tell you from my own experience that just isn’t going to happen.
I defy any transexual human being to tell me that deep down inside they don’t still have some of the emotions related to the body they were born with. Let me explain.
We all dream in our sleep. I dream. Every night I dream. My dreams most frequently are the stuff of Steven King novels and movies. In those dreams I am seeing myself as George and at other times I’m seeing myself as Georgia. If, as many transexuals claim they really are not a person of the sex they were born with, why do their dreams reflect the body they were born with?
Could I be wrong about other people’s dreams? Of course I could. I just don’t think I’m so exceptional as to think I’m different from other people in the same situation. What does make me different is the way I view my reality.
The ongoing joke in our home is when I do something that is out of feminine character, my wife will inevitably accuse “George” of the act. She, as much as I, realize that there are two personalities at work in my character. She even has two pictures of Little Georgie on a shelf right above the nightstand adjacent to her side of the bed. All of this explanation is leading to my real reason for this entry in my blog. That issue is the current push to accept gender confusion in children as something other than what it may not be.
I was in my early thirties when I first began the process of recognizing the dual nature buried deep in my soul. It took another thirty plus years to fully understand that dual nature of my personalities and a full forty years to take the final step required for me to feel complete as Georgia. In that process, I was fully aware of the finality of what I was contemplating. I have referred to it as approaching the Rubicon and then as Caesar stated when he famously emerged on the south side of the Rubicon, “The die is cast.” There would be no do-overs, no chance of reversing course … the die of my life would be cast.
Obviously, it was a slowly developing process for a couple of reasons. The first of those was the fact that the pervading thought among the people I was associating with in the gender community was that in order to make that physical transition I would have to first wipe the emotions that were associated with George completely from my thoughts.
That I had difficulty with because I could not come to grips with the idea of telling my children primarily, and family as well, that I, Georgia was to all intents and purposes killing George and he would cease to exist. I share in my memoir the moment when I realized that wasn’t necessary; that the two “spirits” had in essence been cohabitating my soul for years anyway and that the only change would be that I would become the visible expression just as George had been the visible part with me in the background.
The second reason for the process being a slowly developing one was more practical. Money! I became resigned to never being a complete Georgia and went about living my life with that as the reality of it. I went through the legal process of name and gender change on my driver’s license and all the legal requirements associated with it. But that all changed with the death of Mom. On my way home from her funeral the reality of the impending distribution of her assets and what that would mean for my ability to at last make myself complete began to slowly settle in.
But even then, I proceeded with caution. I was keenly aware of the finality and the seriousness of what I was considering. After all, I had been exposed to the frequency of suicide in the transexual community and the reality that the grass not always greener on the other side of the fence.
Several years earlier I had asked my best friend Christine if I ultimately made that choice if it would make any difference in our relationship. Her answer was, “of course not and that if I ever proceeded with that option, she would go with me wherever I chose to go for the procedure and hold my hand though it all.” So, I called her and asked if the promise she had made at that time was still good. “Of course it is. Just tell me when and where.”
I still didn’t proceed. I spent the next several months thinking about the implications of what I was considering. Finally in February of 2015 at the age of seventy-one I made an appointment with the surgeon I had decided long ago was the one I wanted for that purpose. Her staff wrote to my employer’s insurance company to inquire about coverage for the operation. To my utter surprise it was covered. Five months later I was rolled in to the operating room. And that brings me to the point of what I need to say about adolescent gender re-assignment.
I had never been anesthetized since I was five years old and didn’t know what to expect. I was told by the anesthetist that he would give me something to relax me, then something to put me to sleep and then use general anesthesia during the surgery. Fine. The next thing I was aware of I was back in my hotel room and awake. Then, the one thing I knew was a possibility, but after all my careful deliberations didn’t think would happen to me … happened.
“My God what have I done?”
There it was. That awful feeling of having consciously done something irreversible that I regretted. For me to be having a regret like that just wasn’t acceptable. I immediately went to work on my own emotions and mindset and within a couple of hours I was okay with what I had done and have never seriously looked back. Sure, there are occasions when I wonder how my life would have turned out as just George. But not very often and I still have no regrets.
I’ve had the benefit of living two lives. One as George and one as Georgia. I know what life “could have been” because I lived it for most of my life. In reality I lived a third of it as George without a clue about my existence other than to know I just didn’t feel normal. A third of it as a joint existence so to speak. George worked all week, and I spent the weekend spending his money on clothes and living my life. The last portion of this life has been mine.
It is my worst fear to think that children, even young adults will never have the opportunity to experience life in the sexual context of how they were born long enough to be able to make a rational choice as a young adult about what to do with their bodies. They may never know what might have been. If they still think they were born with a mismatch of emotions and body then make an informed decision about the advantages and disadvantages of making that irreversible decision.
It’s my personal opinion that any teacher who fosters or encourages the children entrusted to their care to make that kind of permanent decision, especially without the parents’ knowledge should be prosecuted to the fullest extent possible. It’s criminal in my opinion. They are taking it upon themselves to encourage children to make decisions for which the teacher will never have to answer for nor deal with those irreversible consequences.
A study done back in the early years of this century estimated that the suicide rate among transexuals was ten to eleven times that of the normal population. Recent studies suggest as many as forty to fifty percent of gender dysphoria affected persons admit contemplating suicide and as many as thirty percent attempting it. I suspect that will spiral to an enormous number in the next ten to twenty years, as a result of the current trend of adolescent gender confusion being fostered by educators, and even by parents yielding to the confused whims of their children.
Even among adults who struggle with gender identity along with other issues such as relationships, job conflicts, social conflicts … the list can be endless. The tendency there is to put all the blame on their gender identity issues and think that if they make that change everything will work itself out. But it seldom does.
In Alcoholics Anonymous there is a scenario that they refer to as a geographical, which is never advisable. It goes like this. Say an alcoholic is living in New York and decides that New York is the problem and that a move to Los Angeles will solve the problem and they won’t want to drink in Los Angeles. New York is the problem. So, they pack up and move to LA. Guess what! All the problems moved with them and the drinking usually becomes worse.
In other words, you have to identify and then solve problems right where you are. Gender identity is no different. Sex reassignment surgery will never solve more than that one problem. And if undergone for the wrong reasons without serious consideration of the possible consequences the result can be utterly tragic.
So I beg anyone who will listen, who will pay attention, to be patient with yourselves, be patient with loved ones who are struggling with gender identity issues whether child or adult but especially children. Proceed with extreme caution. And if you know of any teacher who is fostering gender issues with children in their care get busy and get them fired at the least and jailed if possible. What they are doing is criminal.